Categories: Automotive

Trading your used car vs. selling it privately — what’s right for you?

Written by

Photo credit: The Nest

When it’s time to upgrade your vehicle, you’ll probably face that common dilemma. Should you trade in your car or sell it on your own? Your answer will depend on your car’s condition and the amount of time you have to sell it.
According to an article on the J.D. Power website, popular-model cars in excellent condition with desirable features and low mileage are ideal to sell privately. You’re also a good candidate to sell privately if you have your maintenance records available for potential buyers to review.
Selling your car on your own will usually net you more money than trading in to a dealership. However, selling privately will cost you more time. Private buyers will want to examine your car and possibly take it to their own mechanic. Buyers will also ask about your car’s service and maintenance history, along with any wear and tear and accidents in the car’s history. If you have the time to meet and negotiate with private buyers, this option could be for you.

Photo credit: Jalopanik

On the other hand, if you need to sell your car quickly, or if it’s not in top shape, you might want to consider trading it in to a dealership. Dealerships will take vehicles in any condition, even those that need to be towed. According to the J.D. Power article, trading in to a dealer is quick and easy. You can do it on your schedule, whenever you’d like, and the dealership takes care of all required paperwork.
However, the dealership will offer you less than what you’d get from a private sale. The dealership spends time and money on paperwork and preparing the vehicle for sale or auction, according to the J.D. Power article. But if you want to purchase a newer vehicle from a dealership, your trade-in could reduce or replace your down payment.
When you’re ready to trade in your car or test drive a newer vehicle, make sure to visit an Earnhardt Auto Centers dealership. With 24 locations around the Valley, northern Arizona and in Las Vegas, Earnhardt offers a vast selection and can make an offer on your trade-in too. Visit any Earnhardt Auto Centers location today!

Photo credit: The Nest
Photo credit: Jalopanik
Photo credit: AAA
Carolyn Sostrom

Carolyn Sostrom is a long-time Arizona resident who loves desert sunsets, warm weather and zumba. As a writer, she’s covered technology, medical and travel topics.

Share
Written by

Recent Posts

Barrett-Jackson 2025 takes on Scottsdale, Arizona

Scottsdale, Arizona – It’s time for the annual Barrett-Jackson 2025 car auction! The event officially kicks off on… Read More

4 days ago

The Ultimate Valentine’s Day Gift Guide at Shoppers Supply

Love is in the air! Valentine’s Day is right around the corner and it’s time… Read More

1 week ago

Fort Worth Stock Show & Rodeo 2025

Fort Worth, Texas - The Fort Worth Stock Show & Rodeo is back in 2025… Read More

2 weeks ago

Montana Pro Rodeo Circuit Finals 2025

Great Falls, Montana - The Montana Pro Rodeo Circuit Finals is kicking off on January… Read More

2 weeks ago

The San Diego Rodeo Rides Back into Town

San Diego, California - The San Diego Rodeo returns to Petco Park on January 10-12,… Read More

3 weeks ago

National Western Stock Show 2025

Denver, Colorado – The National Western Stock Show is a truly iconic and world-renowned annual event… Read More

3 weeks ago